Grade: A
Starring: Eddie Redmayne, Felicity Jones, Charlie Cox, David
Thewlis, Maxine Peake and Harry Lloyd
Premise: Shortly after falling in love with a beautiful
young woman at
Rated PG-13 for thematic material including intense
emotional content and some unsettling/disturbing images
What does it mean to truly love somebody?
That question often came up in discussions of last year’s
Spike Jonze film, Her, which was
about the romance between a man and the lively female personality of his
automated home management system. I thought of that movie—and that big
question—while watching The Theory of
Everything today, because it touches on similar ground. In Her, a man becomes happily and fully
committed to a woman he cannot and will not ever see or touch; in Theory, we see a woman serving as lover,
companion and provider to a man who is alive and lucid but can barely function
without her assistance, and can give her almost nothing in return.
The man is, of course, physicist Stephen Hawking, whose
early adulthood bout with “motor-neuron syndrome”—aka Lou Gehrig’s Disease—left
him incapacitated, wheelchair-bound, and, eventually, unable to physically
speak. The woman in the film is Jane Hawking, the physicist’s first wife, on
whose memoir (“Travelling to Infinity: My Life With Stephen”) the movie is
based. As adapted by Anthony McCarten and directed by James Marsh, and acted
out by spirited young actors Eddie Redmayne and Felicity Jones, The Theory of Everything explores the
depths of love, commitment and companionship in the unique dynamic of a relationship
that, despite being between two living, breathing human beings, is unavoidably
(some might say hopelessly) one-sided.
Plot
Then—disaster. After taking a terrible and unexpected fall
on a flat walkway on campus, Stephen goes to the doctor and gets horrible news.
His propensity to fumble away items or to suddenly go stiff in the legs wasn’t
a random illness, a cramp, or clumsiness. He has motor-neuron syndrome, ALS,
Lou Gehrig’s Disease—whatever you choose to call it—and he probably only has
two years to live. Devastated by this diagnosis and realizing he has limited
time left, Stephen decides to throw himself into his studies, to use his
brilliant mind to accomplish and study as much as he can, particularly his
Black Hole Theory. He’s even angry and desperate enough to turn his back on
Jane.
But she won’t have it. Even in light of the diagnosis, Jane
sticks by his side, confesses her love to him, marries him, and has his
children. Stephen becomes a doctor and renowned published author and physicist.
In a remarkable (but often unheeded and unrewarded) show of strength and
selflessness and bravery, Jane feeds Stephen, helps him get dressed, helps him
in and out of his wheelchair, and does what she can to make life as accessible
as possible to him. Even once Stephen loses the ability to speak, and can only
communicate by typing words into a machine that will read them aloud, she’s
faithful and willing. But Jane does have her own needs, and when church choir
director-turned family friend Jonathan Jones (Charlie Cox) confesses feelings
for her, it’s hard not to reciprocate.
What Works?
The Theory of
Everything doesn’t waste any time, having the main characters meet within
five minutes and having warning signs of Stephen’s disease appear almost
equally early. Especially since it’s almost impossible to walk in without
knowing who the protagonist is and what sort of limitations he has, the movie
has got you in its grip right from the get-go. You’re intrigued and cheered by
the easy chemistry between Stephen and Jane (especially when they seem such a
mismatch, with her way out of his league), you’re crushed by the horrible
diagnosis you know is coming, and you’re engaged by scenes of their day-to-day
life, which they make almost normal. And, of course, you end up thoroughly
invested and moved at the hard-working, overlooked Jane’s work behind the
scenes as her husband becomes a world-renowned professor.
The movie is very well-cast, with seasoned veterans like
David Thewlis (Professor Lupin in the Harry
Potter series) and Emily Watson (a two-time Oscar nominee) in supporting
parts, and new faces Charlie Cox and Maxine Peake in key roles as the Hawkings’
respective love interests—the former the warm, supportive male presence Jane
craves and the latter a spunky individual who livens up Stephen’s long, slow
days of trying to communicate. I won’t call this group ‘window dressing’, as
they’re far too effective for that, but it’d be hard to blame anyone who walks
away only remembering the leads.
Redmayne, 32, is best known for his role as the lovelorn
patriot Marius in 2012’s Les Mis, and
he’s done eye-catching work in My Week
With Marilyn and Hick, but what
he does here is astonishing. His complete physical commitment to the role of
the barely-mobile protagonist is riveting, so far beyond acting you barely
remembering you’re watching an actor play Hawking, and not the physicist
himself. Other thoroughly-convincing tour-de-force portrayals of
physically-limited individuals came to mind, such as Daniel Day-Lewis in My Left Foot and Colin Firth in The King’s Speech. Both those guys won
Best Actor Oscars, by the way, and Redmayne will likely be in the conversation
for his portrait, which isn’t always very dignified but is certainly true to
the real figure.
Good as Redmayne is, the real star is the 31-year-old
Felicity Jones, whom audiences might recognize for her small role in last
summer’s Amazing Spider-Man 2 or her
starring role in the 2011 drama Like
Crazy (most remembered now as one of Jennifer Lawrence’s first prominent
films). Jones’s performance is superb, not just for the emotional theatrics she
sometimes must bring to the role, but what the role suggests—a woman who loved
a man enough to put her own needs forever on the back burner, to feed him,
change him, clean him, push his wheelchair, raise his children, defer to his
public genius, and support him fully. There are moments when the strain of
carrying this unenviable burden shows (her first attempt to try to get Stephen
to communicate after he loses the ability to speak altogether is
heartbreaking); the emotion and agony increases dramatically when you remember
the real Jane Hawking did this for twenty-five years of marriage (they divorced
in 1995). It’s a moving, wonderful performance, and likely also puts Jones in
line for an Oscar nomination (for Best Actress, and it would be well-deserved).
What Doesn’t Work?
At just over two hours, The
Theory of Everything isn’t agonizingly-long, and, thankfully for a
fact-based-film, it doesn’t feel much like a history lesson or a documentary,
either. It doesn’t contain a great entertainment factor, so it’s not exactly a
film one would watch over and over, but that’s a small fault. This movie is
very well done.
Content
Audience members who might wonder how on earth Jane and
Stephen Hawking had three kids, given his condition, will be left wondering, as
The Theory of Everything is
impressively clean. I can’t recall any specific profanities (though I’m sure
there are a couple), there’s no violence, and there’s no sensual content beyond
a few kisses. But, of course, the details of Stephen’s symptoms and his
struggle can be difficult to watch and endure—a good portion of the film, while
enlightening, is unavoidably depressing. Younger viewers will
probably have many questions.
Bottom Line
Based on the real-life lengthy marriage between Jane and
Stephen Hawking, The Theory of Everything
can be impressively-enlightening and desperately-sad, but above all it is
truly moving. The principle figures are brought to vivid life in fine
performances by Felicity Jones and Eddie Redmayne, and the stirring dynamic is
one that can and should be pondered and marveled at by viewers for a long time.
What does it mean to really love somebody? How far would you go to show someone
you love them? Is it wrong to crave physical affection when you’re married, but
your spouse is physically unable to provide that physical affection? And how
would you react if you or someone you loved was given such a harsh diagnosis?
This is a profound and affecting movie.
The Theory of Everything (2014)
Directed by James MarshScreenplay by Anthony McCarten
Based on the book “Travelling to Infinity: My Life With Stephen” by Jane Wilde Hawking
Rated PG-13
Length: 123 minutes